The low mortality – only 190 deaths for more than half a million people infected– of the wave of covid-19 that registers Shanghai, the largest city in China, intrigues many experts.
What is the balance?
The Asian giant has contained the balance to less than 5,000 fatalities since the detection of the coronavirus at the end of 2019 in the city of Wuhan, in the center of the country.
As for confirmed infections, they rise to 200,000 symptomatic cases and 470,000 asymptomatic according to official balances.
Shanghai, the city most affected in the country by the omicron variant, registers a mortality rate of 0.036%, that is, 36 deaths per 100,000 infected since March 1.
The rate is lower than that of countries that have become an example of managing the pandemic, such as New Zealand (0.07%).
If Shanghai had had the same fatality rate as the oceanic country, the metropolis would have to have “more than 300 dead“, he stated skeptically. epidemiologist Michael Baker, from the Otago University of New Zealand.
Prabhat Jha, an epidemiologist at the University of Toronto, opined that the mortality from the current outbreak may be “a very high number” given the wide number of elderly unvaccinated and the low efficiency rate of the immunizers used in the country.
What is the explanation?
Since the start of the epidemic, China has followed a covid-zero strategy based on early lockdowns when cases and massive tests are detected to identify all those infected and isolate them.
This method makes it possible to “limit the contagion as much as possible” and “avoid” a saturation of medical resources that would cause more deaths, estimated the epidemiologist Wu Zunyou, one of the figures in the fight against COVID-19 in China.
The repeated large-scale screening part of the population also increases “the chances of detecting (early) asymptomatic cases” or mild, according to virologist Leong Hoe Nam, a resident of Singapore.
According to this theory, the distortion would not be due to the mortality figure but to that of officially detected infections, which would be higher thanks to its strategy to combat the pandemic.
What part of truth?
“Even so, there is still a gap between the identified cases and the people who end up sick and die” from covid, Baker said, suggesting that Shanghai’s balance could grow even more.
In Wuhan, the first city confined at the beginning of the pandemic, the authorities subsequently revised the number of fatalities to increase it by 50%.
Another explanation may be the “very strict criteria for classifying Covid-19-related deaths,” said Paul Tambyah, president of the Asia-Pacific Society for Clinical Microbiology and Infection.
According to this criterion, people with previous pathologies that are aggravated by covid are not included in the official balance if they die after being cured of the virus.
In other countries, the count is broader. The The United Kingdom, for example, includes any deceased person as a victim of the virus. within 28 days of testing positive, “including traffic accident victims,” Tambyah said.
The figures in China are “very political,” says the infectologist Mai He, from the University of Washington.
Especially in this crisis in which the communist power has tried to present its management of the pandemic as proof of the superiority of its authoritarian political system against the deadly balance sheets of many Western democracies.
Unaccounted for cases?
China is “timid” about mortality figures, Ariel Karlinsky, WHO adviser at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, told AFP.
Related news
Comparing the number of deaths from any cause in China since 2020 and comparing it with the years preceding the pandemic would give a fairer view of the situation, this expert estimated.
But you are figures are not public and they were only communicated in detail to “selected researchers”, he lamented.