Judge in Quebec City sword attack trial begins instructions to jury

by


The jurors will have to decide whether Carl Girouard can be held criminally responsible for his acts. Girouard is charged with two counts of murder and five of attempted murder.

The Canadian Press

Frédéric Lacroix-Couture

Police cars close off a street in Old Quebec after the sword attacks of Oct. 31, 2020.
Police cars close off a street in Old Quebec after the sword attacks of Oct. 31, 2020. Photo by ANNE-SOPHIE THILL /AFP via Getty Images

QUEBEC — A Quebec Superior Court judge has begun delivering final instructions to the 11-person jury that will determine the fate of the man accused in Quebec City’s fatal Halloween 2020 sword attack.

Carl Girouard, 26, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of François Duchesne, 56, and Suzanne Clermont, 61. He is also charged with five counts of attempted murder in the attack in the city’s historic Old Quebec district .

He has admitted to using a sword to murder and maim that night, but his defense lawyer has argued he was not criminally responsible because he suffered from a mental disorder.

The Crown contains he was well aware of his actions that night.

The jury will be sequestered on Monday after Justice Richard Grenier concludes his instructions, including the possible verdicts the jurors can consider.

After hearing closing arguments on Wednesday, the judge reminded jurors Thursday of certain general principles in criminal law and the various criteria to evaluate the credibility and value of the testimony.

Experts did not agree on Girouard’s mental state at the time of the attacks, and that he will play a major role in the jury’s deliberations.

Dr. Gilles Chamberland, a psychiatrist testifying on behalf of the defence, concluded that Girouard suffered from schizophrenia and was delirious and in a state of psychosis the night of the killings, unable to distinguish right from wrong.

The Crown’s expert, psychiatrist Dr. Sylvain Faucher, told jurors the accused suffered from a personality disorder and was on a “narcissistic quest” to express his resentment toward society, concluding that there were no signs of delusional thinking and that he knew what he was doing.

This article was produced with financial support from the Meta and Canadian Presse News Scholarships.


Leave a Comment