I want to replace my 2018 Mazda CX-5 with a vehicle that is more capable of towing two motorcycles long distances and doing small jobs around the house. I want to keep the vehicle for 10 years by meticulously performing the recommended maintenance and treating it with an annual rust preventative.
I want something that will keep me away from garages for repairs other than normal maintenance. I was thinking of the 2020 Toyota Tacoma, a 4-door SR5 version with a 6-foot body. Would this be the right choice?
If you are looking for a reliable, durable midsize pickup that can last 10 years without difficulty, the Toyota Tacoma is definitely the place for you. And if in addition you treat it against corrosion and present a perfectly filled maintenance book, you will be able to resell it much more expensive than a Ford Ranger or a Chevrolet Colorado in ten years. Indeed, the Tacoma has one of the best resale values on the market, all vehicles combined.
With the SR5 Double Cab, 6-foot box version, you can tow up to 2,900 kg (6,400 lbs) which is more than enough for two motorcycles. Having a crate that’s long enough will also make it easier for you to complete chores around your house if you need to carry long items.
In contrast, the dynamic behavior of the Tacoma is the opposite of that of the Mazda CX-5. Your current SUV offers a fairly economical engine and dynamic handling, almost sporty in its class. If you really appreciate the feel of your vehicle, you might be disappointed with Toyota’s truck.
The Tacoma offers a more typical pickup truck driving style. First, its driving position, with very elongated legs, is reminiscent of the trucks of yesteryear, and may displease some drivers. In the back, you’ll have less space than in your CX-5, even with the double cab. If it is your family vehicle, this could be penalizing.
On the road, the Tacoma’s V6 will be much more greedy than the 4-cylinder of your CX-5. We are talking about a difference of 3 L / 100 km, but it will be more important if you drive a lot in town. The good news is, this engine is indestructible if properly maintained.
Our advice would be to go and test drive the vehicle to get an idea. If the faults mentioned above don’t bother you more than that, go for it!
In video: Ford Ranger or Toyota Tacoma?