An 85-year-old law paves the way for Canadians to fight in Ukraine

By: Tyler Wentzell, University of Toronto

Ukrainian President Volodymr Zelensky recently announced that Ukraine’s armed forces will welcome foreign volunteers and build an international brigade following Russia’s invasion of his country.

Soon after his announcement, British Foreign Secretary Liz Truss expressed her support for Britons seeking to fight for Ukraine. Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister of Foreign Affairs Mélanie Joly made similar remarks:

“We understand that people of Ukrainian descent want to support their fellow Ukrainians and also that there is a desire to defend the motherland and in that sense it is their own individual decision…. Let me be clear: we are all very supportive of any form of support to Ukrainians right now.”

Canadian Defense Minister Anita Anand similarly told “all foreigners willing to defend Ukraine and world order” to contact the foreign diplomatic missions of Ukraine.

calls for help

Ukraine’s call for foreign volunteers is nothing new. Embattled nations have long called upon adventurers, diasporas, religious adherents and ideological sympathizers to join in their struggles. Canadians have an equally long history of answering such calls, including during the US Civil War in the 1860s and the Spanish Civil War in the 1930s.

These volunteers can play a variety of roles. In some cases, they might be specialists like pilots or medical doctors who are in short supply and are urgently needed. In other conflicts, foreign volunteers can appreciably add to the mass of a country’s military force.

Regardless of the quantity or type of volunteers, the call for help is perhaps most important in signaling a simple message: we are not alone. Zelensky is unambiguously telling the world that Ukraine’s fight is everyone’s fight; Ukraine’s cause is everyone’s cause. And once foreign volunteers are in place, this message becomes clearer and stronger.

Hockey fans in the stands hold up the Ukrainian flag before an NHL game.
Winnipeg Jets fans hold the Ukraine flag as the Hoosli Ukrainian Male Chorus sings the Ukrainian and Canadian national anthems before the game against the Montréal in Winnipeg. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Greenslade

The plight of the Ukrainian people is there for all to see on social media right now — imagine the impact of videos from the front lines narrated by a Torontoniana Winnipegger or an Edmontonian?

This type of involvement in war zones is what the Canadian government has sought to avoid in the past. Getting Canadians home amid or after a conflict, whether they’re released from service or held in prisoner-of-war camps, costs money and political capital.

Claims of neutrality are questioned

Volunteers fighting in foreign wars can lead foreign governments and voters to question a country’s claims of neutrality if it has opted not to get directly involved in the conflict.

Killed or wounded Canadians can also ignite heated debates about what constitutes a veteran since they’re not members of the Canadian Armed Forces, and who will provide for the returned volunteers or their families.

These issues can be particularly challenging when they illuminate sectarian or ideological divides.

Just before Confederation in 1867, as many as 50,000 Canadians went to fight for American federal forces during the US Civil War, even as other British North Americans supported the Confederacy, most notably in the Maritimes. Recruiters were prosecuted in police courtsbut not the volunteers themselves.

A black-and-white photo shows a man in a suit and tie gesturing as he speaks into a microphone.
Québec Premier Maurice Duplessis gestures as he delivers a speech during the 1956 provincial election. (CP Photo)

In the Spanish Civil War (1936-39), nearly 1,700 Canadian volunteers fought to defend Spain’s elected government.

Others, notably conservatives in Québec like Premier Maurice Duplessis, Decried the volunteer movement’s connection to the Communist Party of Canada and lauded the leader of the nationalist rebellion, Gen. Francisco Franco, as the hero of Catholicism.

The Foreign Enlistment Act

These tensions caused a unity crisis and compelled Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King and Justice Minister Ernest Lapointe to pass the country’s Foreign Enlistment Act in 1937. They applied the act to the situation in Spain by an order-in-council.

The act remains in effect today. It prohibits Canadians from joining the armed forces of any nation “at war with any friendly state.” So in a conflict in which Canada is genuinely neutral, that means Canadians can’t join the armed forces of any belligerent party.

In the present war, the statute would prohibit a Canadian from joining the Russian military — but not Ukraine’s.

A black-and-white headshot of a grey-haired man in a suit and tie.
An undated photo of William Lyon Mackenzie King. (CP PHOTO/Public Archives)

In 1937, the act allowed King and Lapointe to argue they were doing something about Canadian volunteers in Spain. Recruiters, largely organized by the Communist Party of Canada, kept most of their efforts underground and quiet to avoid prosecution.

The Canadian volunteers were not seriously investigated. Although charges were nearly pressed against the recruiters, the endeavor was abandoned when the RCMP and the Department of Justice feared public backlash.

The act’s prohibition on recruiting is broad. It’s an offense to recruit within Canada for the armed forces of any state, friendly or hostile.

However, consular and diplomatic officers of that foreign state are allowed to engage in such activities. This is presumably why Canadian officials have pointed potential volunteers to Ukrainian embassies and consulates. Any prospective grassroots recruiters would be wise to take the same approach.

A man wipes away tears as he sits in a church.
A man wipes away tears as members of the Ukrainian community attend a service at a Ukrainian Orthodox Church in Surrey, BC THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck

Canada is largely behind Ukraine

The tensions exacerbated by Canadian volunteers in previous wars, and the corresponding desire for strategic ambiguity by the federal government, aren’t present in the current crisis. Canadians seem to be universally in Ukraine’s corner.

People's legs and feet are seen under a giant Ukrainian flag.
A large Ukrainian flag is carried through Toronto as thousands gather to show their support for the people of Ukraine following the Russian invasion. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young

The statements by Joly and Anand have helped eliminate ambiguity at a moment when time is of the essence. This is not to say that the other costs of foreign volunteerism will vanish. If Canadian volunteers go to Ukraine, some will undoubtedly be killed or captured. But as Joly has indicated, this is a risk the volunteers must accept of their own volition.

After Ukraine and Russia, Canada is home to more people of Ukrainian descent than any other country on Earth. The 2016 census shows 1.4 million Canadians of Ukrainian ancestrya third of which are aged 25 to 54 — in other words, of fighting age.

We can only guess how many of them might contemplate the idea, but if even a fraction elect to make the journey, there could soon be large numbers of Canadians in Ukraine.

Tyler WentzellSJD candidate, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Leave a Comment