Sunday, January 17

Climate: “The Affair of the Century” finally arrives in court

Two years after the launch of this procedure, accompanied by 2.3 million signatories of an unprecedented online petition, the four requesting NGOs – Notre Affaire à tous, Greenpeace France, Fondation Nicolas Hulot and Oxfam France – find the representatives of the State before the administrative tribunal of Paris.

If The Affair of the Century wins, it would be a landmark decision for climate justice in France. It would put the politician in front of his ecological contradictions: a lot of speeches and very few acts“, Cécilia Rinaudo, coordinator of Notre Affaire à tous, told AFP.

The conviction of a state for climate inaction would be historic, and not only in France“, continues Cécile Duflot, Executive Director of Oxfam France, emphasizing the parallel with the Urgenda affair, which has become the model for the recent rise in climate justice.

In December 2019, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands ordered the Dutch government to reduce the country’s greenhouse gas emissions by at least 25% by the end of 2020.

But a final decision of the French justice is not yet for tomorrow.

On Thursday, the conclusions of the public protractor, of which the parties have received an overview, will be listened to with attention, even if they will not necessarily be followed by the court.

We are optimistic on reading the meaning of the rapporteur’s conclusions“, assures Cécilia Rinaudo.

According to corroborating sources, he should ask for the recognition of a failure of the State to respect its own commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

– “Not a sole” –

The government rejects accusations of inaction, highlighting in particular the energy-climate law of 2019 which “strengthens climate goals“, by targeting carbon neutrality by 2050 or a 40% drop in fossil fuel consumption by 2030.

But last November, the Council of State, in a decision qualified as “historical“by defenders of the planet, himself noted that France, which has committed to reducing its emissions by 40% by 2030 compared to 1990, has exceeded the carbon budgets it had set itself .

And the highest French administrative court, seized by the municipality of Grande-Synthe which considers itself threatened with submersion on the northern coast, has given the State three months to justify its actions in terms of reducing CO2 emissions. .

This decision, which is in addition to that of the same jurisdiction which gave six months in July to the state to act against air pollution under penalty of a record penalty, encourages environmental activists.

We can clearly see that there is a hardening of the tone of French justice towards the State when it does not respect its own commitments, and behind, the right of populations to live in a healthy environment.“, tells AFP Marie Toussaint, co-founder of Notre Affaire à tous, now an environmental MEP.

The NGOs, which will mobilize their activists online Thursday for lack of being able to bring them to court, also hope that a legal victory could change the political balance of power at a time when the bill resulting from the proposals of the Citizens’ Convention for the climate, which they consider to be well below the stake, will soon be presented to the Council of Ministers.

We hope for a start“, comments Cécile Duflot.”Our deep will is not to condemn the State, it is for the State to act“, said the former minister to AFP.

And regardless of the decision of the court at first instance, then on appeal possibly, “There is a real movement around The Affair of the Century, which will not let go of the State with a sole“, promises Jean-François Julliard, director of Greenpeace France.



Robin Rivaton, economist.By Robin Rivaton

Lbest of all worlds

For Sylvain Fort, it is good to have a self-confident, powerful and trained State which does not hesitate to make full use of the considerable levers it possesses.By Sylvain Fort


France, Paris, December 14, 2019, portrait of François Bazin.Francois Bazin

Evaccination emergency

Nicolas bouzou

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *